Thursday, February 16, 2012

256: Review: Zooey Deschanel Hosts SNL

Of all the Saturday Night Live hosts this season, Zooey Deschanel was one of the most anticipated, announced in late 2011 and hyped in commercials online and on air.

From being the blond actress in Elf to the adorable female component of She & Him to the quirky New Girl star, Deschanel has won admiration from both indie and mainstream audiences without betraying either of these bases. Hipsters and sitcom lovers alike waited excitedly to see how Deschanel would act on SNL.

One Vulture commenter said that it was the best SNL episode since the '90s, and many other commenters agreed that it was at least the best episode of the current season. 

But how much of this was because of Deschanel, and how much was because of the week's surrounding events -- Santorum's primary successes, the Super Bowl, etc.? Was Deschanel a better host than others this season?

Photo: Vulture
Deschanel's monologue didn't stray far from her “quirky” celebrity persona. She wore a heart-printed dress and performed a song about men forgetting Valentine's Day, complete with a ukulele performance. 

While her monologue may have been relatively predictable, Deschanel proved that even though she’s the star of a major network television show, she can still sing beautifully. Her musical performance was arguably better than that of Karmin, a pop duo whose performance was lackluster at best. After the Lana del Ray fiasco, though, the SNL producers were probably wise in choosing a lesser-known artist with few expectations as the episode’s musical guest.

In general, Deschanel stuck with the “adorkable” persona during the other sketches as well, straying away from any performances that might be deemed offensive or mean-spirited. The first sketch about M.I.A.’s hand gesture during the Super Bowl was the only time Deschanel hinted at mockery, and even that sketch was fairly light-hearted.

Running sketches like "Technology Hump" and "Les Jeunes De Paris," while not exclusive to Deschanel's episode, seemed more innocent with her performance. The cameo by Jean Dujardin, star of The Artist, was also a nice, unexpected addition to the latter performance.

In "Being Quirky with Zooey Deschanel," where Abby Elliott played Deschanel and Deschanel herself played Mary Kate Olsen, we learned two things: that Deschanel isn't afraid to laugh at herself and what people think of her, and that she can really act. The Mary Kate impression was spot-on, and her impersonation was much more convincing than the Very Mary Kate series of internet renown. Taran Killam’s Michael Cera impression rounded out the innocent factor and added levity to an already laugh-worthy sketch.

What were arguably the episode's most memorable sketches, though, didn't include Deschanel. 
Bill Hader's three-part series imitating Chrysler's Super Bowl commercials with Clint Eastwood stole the show, simultaneously poking fun at other Super Bowl ads as well as Chrysler's. With senseless lists of product placement and criticism of traditional American values such as being able to drive a Chrysler, Hader left a lasting impression on viewers, even if that impression was simply one of him wearing pants raised to unnatural heights.

Nicholas Cage's guest appearance with Andy Samberg on "Weekend Update" was a great wrap-up to Samberg's recurring Cage impersonation in the "Get in the Cage" sketches. Like Deschanel, Cage wasn’t afraid to poke fun at his own performances, joking that all of his movies include speaking at two levels: whispering and shouting.

And the Deschanel sketches with predictable endings, "Front Page" and "Patio Party," seemed like time-fillers that were mediocre at best. Kristen Wiig can play many roles! But we didn’t need to insert a doe-eyed Deschanel into a 1950s-style newsroom and a Southern crab dinner to know that.

While this episode showed that Deschanel can act and that SNL front-runners like Jason Sudeikis and Bill Hader can carry on a great show, it did evoke nostalgia for SNL seasons past with Tina Fey and Amy Poehler, whose performances made any guest hosts’ episodes shine. 

But perhaps that's what the writers intended, since next week's host is Maya Rudolph.

No comments:

Post a Comment